What General Contractors, Project Owners and Property Owners Need to Know about NY Labor Law
July 28, 2021
What General Contractors, Project Owners and Property Owners Need to Know about NY Labor Law

NY State is one of the toughest states to comply with business laws and regulations. Not only are the tax laws and statutory requirements some of the most stringent in the country, but we also have some of the strictest laws when it comes to worker’s rights and employer’s responsibilities. Often business owners believe that because they do not have employees that they do not have liability from the same types of claims that an employer might face in the case of an injured worker. In NY state you couldn’t be farther from the truth. The sole remedy of an employer is a worker’s compensation employer’s liability policy which statutorily protects the employer from being sued under any other liability. That’s where the property owner, project owner or the GC come in, after the injured worker calls Dewey Cheatum and How, they are advised that there are other “responsible parties” to access and may be seen as deep pockets. There is typically no such coverage afforded to those who do not have employees under a general liability policy unless that policy is endorsed to include these types of claims.


When it comes to people working on projects in which you have control you have a web of litigation land mines that are hard to navigate and hard to purchase risk transfer products without breaking the bank. The origination of these laws that affect owners without direct employees were enacted over 100 years ago and still persist today creating a legal environment heavily in favor of workers and their rights to be compensated adequately for injuries sustained while working for others.


Three Laws Employers Should Know About

The statutes in question are actually three different laws but are commonly referred to by several monikers such as “third party action-over”, the “scaffold law”, “fall from height”, or just plain “labor law.” The law refers to sections 200, 240 and 241 of the NY State labor law.


  • Labor Law § 200 (the Safe Work Environment Statute) requires a reasonably safe work environment for all employees and others legally at the worksite. Employers must properly maintain, guard, and light the worksite, safely operate machinery, equipment, and other devices.
  • Labor Law § 240(1) (the Scaffold, Ladder and Working at a Height Statute) has been interpreted by New York courts to impose a nondelegable duty to provide safety devices to protect against elevation-related hazards on construction sites. Project owners and general contractors are absolutely liable for any violation that results in an injury, regardless of whether the project owner or general contractor (GC) supervised or controlled the work.5 Further, the worker’s own negligence will not bar or reduce the worker’s recovery.
  • Labor Law § 241(6) (the Construction, Excavation and Demolition Work Statute) imposes a nondelegable duty on project owners and GCs to keep workplaces safe from trip and slip hazards and other related hazards. A plaintiff seeking damages pursuant to this statute is not required to show that the project owner or GC exercised supervision or control over his worksite to establish a right of recovery. However, a violation under this statute, unlike a violation of Labor Law § 240(1), is only evidence of negligence on the part of project owner or GC. Absolute liability is not imposed by proof of a violation; therefore, the injured worker’s contributory and comparative negligence are considered viable defenses to a claim under this section

 

Responsible Parties

These laws allow an injured worker to collect workers compensation benefits from their employer as well as litigate against other “responsible parties.” These other “responsible parties” are subject to absolute liability, meaning common law negligence standards don’t apply. This is known as a third-party-over action, a type of action in which an injured employee, after collecting workers compensation benefits from the employer, sues a third party for contributing to the employee’s injury. Typically, the target of such suits are project owners or general contractors for damages such as:


  • Lost Wages;
  • Medical Expenses;
  • Pain and suffering; and
  • Any other damage, as the court may see fit.


These laws apply to employers, general contractors, property owners and their agents. A property owner includes any person with an interest in the property and any person who fulfills the role of owner by contracting to have work performed on the property for his or her benefit. This definition includes anyone who may have leased the property but retains the right to control how the work is to be performed on the property.


New York courts have consistently held that an entity is subject to Section 200’s duty of care if it exercises supervisory control over the work performed on the property. The courts have also clarified that merely monitoring the timing and quality of the work is not sufficient to establish control. 


Good Defense needs Offense


The underlying purpose of these laws which were enacted over 100 years ago, is to ensure that construction workers injured on job sites receive fair compensation for the losses they suffer. Over the years, New York courts have broadened the scope of these statutes and adapted them to modern worksite dangers. At the same time, juries in the five boroughs have consistently awarded large verdicts to injured workers who allege violations of these laws. This confluence of factors has created unique challenges for risk transfer: insurance premiums are higher and beneficial coverage terms are harder to obtain. Even when you’re not doing work downstate you still can be subject to litigation; we have the same laws, just not the same judicial environment, YET.


Recommendations

  • Use vetted contracts
  • Seek the advice of council for contract agreements
  • Know what is in the contract and what each requirement means
  • If you choose to seek liability insurance covering this type of action speak with your trusted insurance advisor early on and allow adequate time for marketing

               



Sign up for our newsletter.

April 15, 2025
It’s April 15—Tax Day in the U.S.—and if you’re a business owner or HR professional, chances are W-2s, filings, and compliance have been front and center for weeks (if not months). But here’s the thing: tax season doesn’t have to be stressful. The right payroll and HCM technology can turn what’s traditionally a time-consuming, error-prone scramble into a streamlined, accurate, and surprisingly painless process. From automatically balancing year-to-date totals to generating and distributing W-2s on time, a robust payroll system ensures nothing slips through the cracks. No more cross-checking data across platforms, no more last-minute tax filings, and no more anxiety about penalties or missed deadlines. At Simco, we get it—because we help businesses simplify this process every single day. The Challenges of Traditional Payroll Tax Management If you're still managing payroll taxes manually—or using disconnected software systems—it’s all too easy to fall behind. Some common issues employers face include: Human error : Tax calculations, forms, and deadlines are complex. A small mistake can lead to penalties or costly overpayments. Time-consuming manual work : Without automation, payroll processing can involve endless imports, exports, and reconciling data across multiple platforms. Compliance risk : With ever-changing tax laws at the federal, state, and local levels, staying compliant can become overwhelming without the right tools. How the Right Technology Can Make Tax Season a Breeze Today’s modern payroll and HCM systems are designed to simplify these challenges. Here’s how the right technology can help: 1. Automated Tax Filing and Payments: An integrated payroll system automates tax calculations, deductions, and filings. Forms like W-2s and W-3s are automatically generated, filed, and paid—without manual input. This reduces the risk of late filings, penalties, and missed deadlines, ensuring compliance with the IRS and state tax agencies. 2. Streamlined W-2 Management: W-2s can be a headache to manage—especially if you have complex tax scenarios like multi-state employment. With an automated system, W-2s are generated and distributed electronically, ensuring accuracy even in complex situations. Employees receive the correct form without you having to spend valuable time cross-checking or manually making corrections. 3. Self-Balancing Capabilities: A self-balancing payroll system ensures that your year-to-date totals and tax filings are accurate, eliminating the need for extensive manual reconciliation. By automatically matching figures in real-time, it streamlines year-end reporting, providing peace of mind when the filing deadline approaches. 4. Fewer Third-Party Imports and Exports: With everything integrated into a single platform, you won’t need to rely on third-party software or services for tax filing and reporting. This means fewer opportunities for errors, fewer manual imports and exports, and significant time saved during payroll processing. 5. Automated Adjustments and Updates: Tax laws and rates change frequently. With the right payroll system, you won’t have to worry about manually updating deductions or tax rates. The system automatically applies changes—whether it’s an update to federal tax rates or state-specific deductions—so your payroll is always up to date. 6. Expert Support When You Need It: Even with the best technology, tax season can present complex challenges. That’s why it’s important to have access to expert support. Whether you need help with multi-jurisdiction filings, audit preparation, or just have questions about tax return procedures, our team of HCM Specialists at Simco is here to provide guidance and ensure that you’re compliant every step of the way. Why Choose Simco for Smarter Payroll and Tax Management? As an isolved Network Partner, we offer a fully integrated payroll and tax management system that is built to handle the complexities of tax season—and beyond. We provide businesses with the tools they need to automate tax filings, ensure compliance, and streamline payroll processing. Here's how we do it: All-in-One Payroll & Tax Platform : From payroll processing to tax deposits and W-2 filings, everything happens within one system, reducing manual work and the risk of errors. Automatic Filing & Timely Accuracy : Federal, state, and local tax filings are completed automatically and on time, ensuring your employees receive only one accurate W-2 form—even in multi-state tax scenarios. Error-Free Tax Reporting : Our self-balancing ledger helps reduce errors and simplifies reconciliation, making tax reporting easier and faster. Expert Support : Whether it’s navigating multi-jurisdictional filings, preparing for an audit, or handling amendments, our team is always available to offer expert advice and assistance. Cost-Effective Solutions : We offer top-tier tech at competitive pricing, often matching or beating our competitors (learn about the Simco Price Match Commitment here !), while providing the personalized service that large providers can’t. Let’s Make Next Tax Season Easier, Starting Today It’s never too early to think about next year. With our unified payroll/HCM solution at Simco, you can save time, reduce stress, and ensure compliance all year long. It’s time to upgrade your payroll system to one that works smarter, not harder. Let’s chat and explore how we can help streamline your payroll and tax processes, so you can focus on growing your business with confidence.
April 4, 2025
New month, fresh start! But let’s be real—how many times have you set a goal, only to watch it fizzle out? Maybe it was too vague, too ambitious, or just got buried under the daily chaos. If you’re tired of spinning your wheels, it’s time to take a smarter approach—literally. Enter SMART goals —your secret weapon for turning ideas into reality. Whether you’re looking to improve employee retention, streamline operations, or boost revenue, this framework ensures your goals don’t just sound good but actually get done . The SMART Formula for Success Specific – Get laser-focused. A goal like “improve employee morale” is too broad. Instead, ask yourself: What does success look like? Are you reducing turnover? Increasing engagement scores? Define it. Measurable – Numbers don’t lie. How will you know if you’ve succeeded? Instead of saying, “increase engagement,” set a target: “Boost employee engagement scores by 5%.” Tracking progress keeps you accountable. Achievable – Dream big, but stay realistic. Sure, we’d all love zero employee turnover, but is it feasible? Probably not. However, reducing turnover by 15%? Now that’s a goal within reach. Relevant – Align with the bigger picture. Every goal should move your business forward. If your focus is employee retention, then prioritizing revenue growth over culture initiatives might not be the best move. Keep your goals aligned. Time-Bound – Set the clock. “Improve retention” is a nice thought, but without a deadline, it’s just wishful thinking. Instead, say, “Increase retention by 5% by the end of the year.” A firm timeline drives action. Track It or Lose It A goal without tracking is just a wish. You wouldn’t set out on a road trip without checking the map, so why leave your goals to chance? Regular progress check-ins—whether through weekly reports, monthly reviews, or real-time dashboards—help keep you on course. Tracking not only highlights wins but also flags roadblocks early, giving you the chance to pivot before it’s too late. And here’s the key: don’t just track for the sake of tracking—use the data to refine your approach. For example, imagine you're aiming to improve employee engagement scores by 5% by the end of the year. After tracking progress for a few months, you notice that engagement is lagging in one department. Instead of waiting until the year-end review, you dig deeper. Perhaps it’s due to lack of recognition or unclear communication—adjustments are made, and suddenly, the department starts seeing improvement. Tracking allows you to course-correct in real-time, ensuring that you hit your target rather than missing the mark. The most successful businesses aren’t the ones that never face setbacks—they’re the ones that track, adapt, and push forward. How We Use SMART Goals to Stay Ahead At Simco, we don’t just talk about SMART goals—we live by them. Our team follows the Entrepreneurial Operating System (EOS) , which helps us stay focused, aligned, and results-driven. A big part of EOS is setting Rocks —key priorities for the next 90 days. And guess what? Every Rock follows the SMART framework: Clearly defined objectives Measurable success markers Challenging yet attainable goals Aligned with our company vision Locked in with a firm 90-day deadline This system keeps us accountable, making sure we’re always moving the needle in the right direction. Your Turn: Take Action Today No more “someday” goals— today is the day to take control. Whether you’re aiming to increase revenue, refine your processes, or boost employee satisfaction, the SMART approach ensures you’re not just busy—you’re making real progress. Need help aligning your HR, payroll, or benefits strategy with your business goals? Simco is here to help . Let’s make this your most productive quarter yet!
April 1, 2025
April Fools' Day is often the perfect opportunity for some lighthearted fun at the office. Whether it's a harmless prank, a funny email, or a playful desk setup, these moments of levity can help break up the monotony of the workday and bring smiles to your team. However, as many HR professionals know, it’s essential to strike a balance between fun and professionalism. While the intention behind pranks is typically harmless, they can sometimes cross boundaries and lead to uncomfortable situations, or worse, legal risks. Recently, an example came to light where one employee thought it would be funny to place a suggestive image on a coworker's desk. The issue arose when another employee saw the image and was offended, leading to a formal complaint. This scenario highlights the importance of knowing where to draw the line between lighthearted fun and inappropriate behavior. A Fine Line: When Fun Turns into Harassment Even if a prank isn't directly targeted at the offended person, it can still create a hostile work environment, especially if it makes someone uncomfortable. As an employer, it's crucial to ensure that your workplace remains respectful and free from harassment. If a prank results in a complaint, it's essential to follow your company's policies to investigate and address the situation. Proper documentation of your investigation and the actions taken is vital to demonstrate that you've fulfilled your obligations as an employer and to protect the organization in case of any future disputes. Setting Clear Expectations To avoid similar issues in the future, it's a good idea to review and clarify your company's stance on pranks and personal conduct in the workplace. Setting expectations starts with having a clear written policy that outlines what is and isn’t acceptable behavior, especially regarding pranks. Consider creating a set of guidelines that all employees can refer to, and be sure these expectations are communicated effectively to everyone. Here are a few tips to guide you: Establish a Formal Policy: Clearly define the boundaries of acceptable humor in your workplace. The policy should cover both pranks and jokes, specifying that while fun is encouraged, it should not come at the expense of respect, inclusion, or professionalism. Communicate Expectations Clearly: Include these guidelines in your employee handbooks or conduct policies, and ensure they’re reviewed during onboarding. Hold periodic team meetings to remind everyone about the importance of maintaining a respectful environment and reinforcing your stance on pranks. Set the Tone from Leadership: Managers and leaders should set an example when it comes to humor in the workplace. They should demonstrate the type of jokes or pranks that are acceptable and ensure their actions align with company policy. Employees are more likely to follow suit when they see their leaders taking these matters seriously. Encourage Open Communication: Foster a culture where employees feel comfortable speaking up if they feel a joke or prank crosses the line. Providing a safe outlet to discuss concerns without fear of retribution will help create an open, transparent environment where everyone feels heard. Categories of Pranks and Jokes That Cross the Line While there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, there are certain categories of pranks and jokes that should generally be off limits in the workplace . These pranks have the potential to cause harm, create discomfort, or violate company policies. By categorizing these behaviors, you can help employees better understand where to draw the line. Sexual or Gender-Based Humor : Avoid pranks with suggestive content, gestures, or language that can create a hostile work environment or be considered harassment. Discriminatory Jokes : Refrain from jokes targeting someone's race, religion, gender, sexual orientation, or other protected characteristics, as they can be harmful and illegal.  Invasive Pranks : Don’t tamper with personal belongings or invade others' personal space, as this undermines comfort and respect. Work Disruptions : Pranks that interfere with productivity or damage equipment should be avoided, as they can hurt overall efficiency. Aggressive or Harmful Pranks : Any prank that causes physical harm or emotional distress, including pranks involving physical touch or intimidation, is off-limits. Creating a Culture of Respect and Fun The key to managing pranks and other fun activities is to cultivate a workplace culture where employees feel comfortable, respected, and empowered. Rather than banning all pranks, focus on fostering a professional environment where employees understand the line between harmless fun and actions that could potentially harm or offend others. Encourage employees to engage in team-building activities and moments of levity that unite them in a positive and inclusive way, without crossing into territory that could lead to complaints or workplace tensions. As April Fools' Day passes, it’s important to remember that while pranks can provide a bit of comic relief, they should never come at the expense of respect or professionalism. By setting clear boundaries, encouraging open communication, and ensuring all employees understand your policies, you can create a workplace where everyone feels comfortable—whether they're laughing at a harmless joke or focusing on their next big project. Have fun in the workplace—but always ensure that a good laugh never comes at the expense of respect or professionalism!

Have a question? Get in touch.