Causes of Current Recruiting and Retention Difficulties and Strategies to Overcome Them
January 26, 2022
Causes of Current Recruiting and Retention Difficulties and Strategies to Overcome Them

Employee attraction and retention have become major obstacles for most employers more so now than ever before. In fact, 67% of employers today consider attraction and retention somewhat of a challenge, according to Zywave’s 2021 Human Resources Benchmarking Overview. Most companies, regardless of industry are experiencing a change in candidate and employee behavior and expectations. These changes in employee/candidate expectations and behavior are rapidly driving necessary change in recruiting and retention strategies. To be competitive in the current market employers must adapt to these changing behaviors and expectations.


Causes of Recruiting and Retention Difficulties


The past 2 years of a global pandemic have rapidly and significantly impacted how we interact within our world. These changes have impacted our economy, social interactions, political landscape, healthcare system, etc. One of the most dramatic changes brought on by the pandemic has occurred between in our interaction and expectations between our personal and professional lives. This has created a change in the psychological contract aka mutual beliefs, perceptions, and informal obligations between an employee and employer.


The COVID-19 pandemic has been the catalyst that created a shift in thinking about what matters most in our lives. It has created a new set of priorities for people and revolutionized the idea that our personal and professional lives must be separate from one another and that they should have as little impact as possible on one another. Employees and prospective employees are now becoming less concerned with job stability and more likely to initiate job/career changes due to opportunities for better pay, benefits, and flexibility.


These expectations, coupled with external factors, have led to supply and demand issues within the labor market and created both a ‘Talent War’ and ‘The Great Resignation’. During the pandemic there was an increase in the unemployment rate and jobs available coupled with low levels of participation in the workforce. This formula created an environment that provided employees the power and motivation to change employers, jobs, and careers. Historically, employers were the entities with the most amount of power; this has since shifted to employees and prospective staff. Employees are now resigning at record rates due to the surplus of available job and ability to choose how, when, and where and why they want to work. Experts believe that supply and demand for workers will eventually come back into balance but that many of the changes in how companies recruit and hire talent will remain long after the pandemic subsides.


Strategies

Develop an Employee Value Proposition (EVP)

 It is essential that employers strategically develop an Employee Value Proposition (EVP) that is unique to their company. “It encompasses the central reasons that people are proud and motivated to work there, such as the inspiring vision or distinctive culture. It is crucial to make sure your EVP is unique, relevant, and compelling. When integrated into all aspects of a business, a strong EVP will help retain top performers and attract the best external talent.”


*Flexibility in Work/Life Balance*

Work should enhance an employee’s quality of life; not decrease it. Work-life flexibility is about creating a culture where employees meet the demands of their personal lives while maintaining high levels of work performance. Companies that prioritize work/life balance statistically experience higher levels of productivity/performance and overall employee engagement.


Reflect on what arrangements are possible and realistic for your organization and consider the following:


  • Re-vamp or consider providing enhancing PTO/Sick/Personal time
  • Provide flexible working arrangements
  •   Remote work
  •   Flextime
  •   Condensed scheduling
  •   Job sharing
  • For front line workers who can’t work remotely flexibility and predictability in scheduling is vital


Conduct Salary Benchmarking

“Salary benchmarking helps your organization to ensure that your internal pay rates remain competitive within your local pay markets. In today's competitive talent landscape, benchmarking allows you to assess how you're positioned relative to market, enabling you to make smart pricing decisions that enable you to attract and retain top talent. While salary benchmarking is a critical part of the annual compensation cycle, it is ultimately only as good as the data - and the process - through which you benchmark.”


Benefits

“Health benefits are always important and it’s no surprise that the Covid pandemic has placed them front and center. According to a recent employee benefits survey, when choosing between a high-paying job and a lower-paying job with quality health benefits, 88% of employees would consider the lower paying job.”

Consider adding or increasing the employer contribution the following benefits…


  • Medical, dental, vision,
  • HRA, FSA, HSA
  • 401(k)
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • Fitness perks
  • Discounts for products/services
  • Health, legal, and financial counseling
  • Leave to care for self and/or family members
  • Allowances for home office technology


Reimagine Professional Development 

Offering learning and development (L&D) programs can be a powerful investment in a company’s future success. It can encourage lateral and upward internal growth and allow your company to stay up to date with changing industry knowledge and trends. L&D also aids in succession planning.


  • Provide tuition reimbursement or a learning allowance
  • Encourage participation in professional organizations
  • Provide opportunities for increases in duties and responsibilities
  • Provide mentorship or leadership development programs
  • Create internal career paths


Streamline Employee Application and Hiring Process

Optimize your job posting and simplify the application process by reducing the number of steps to apply for a job. “According to some studies, 60% of job candidates abandon their online applications because the process took too long or was too complex (some estimate the rate is even higher). For employers, this churn results in loss of top talent, reduced ROI on recruitment investments, and potentially bad reviews from would-be candidates.”


  • Be innovative and incorporate the company’s mission, vision, values into the process
  • Utilize a realistic recruiting technique in provide positives and negatives of the job
  • Be actively engaged in company banding use of social media
  • Personalize a candidate’s experience by telling a story/playing to the human experience
  • Speed up the hiring process, many candidates have several offers to choose from
  • Improve communication at every step in the process


Re-Vamp Employee Referral Programs

Employee referral programs help increase attachment to the organization and make employees feel as though they have a stake in the future of the business.


  • Reduce hiring time & recruiting costs
  • Increase employee retention rate
  • Increase ease in recruiting for hard to fill roles


If you need assistance with implementing any of these strategies, please contact your Simco HR Account Executive.

 



Sources:

https://www.michaelpage.co.uk/advice/management-advice/attraction-and-recruitment/create-great-employee-value-proposition#:~:text=An%20employee%20value%20proposition%20(EVP,they%20bring%20to%20a%20company.&text=When%20integrated%20into%20all%20aspects,attract%20the%20best%20external%20talent.

https://www.peoplekeep.com/blog/the-most-important-benefits-to-employees

https://www.salary.com/blog/understanding-the-salary-benchmarking-process/#:~:text=Salary%20benchmarking%2C%20also%20called%20compensation,pay%20rate%20for%20each%20position.

https://www.lucidchart.com/blog/how-to-streamline-the-job-application-process

Sign up for our newsletter.

September 2, 2025
Many businesses rely on multiple vendors to manage critical functions such as HR, payroll/HCM, benefits, commercial insurance, and retirement plans. While outsourcing can provide specialized expertise in each area, using separate providers often creates hidden costs that can quietly undermine efficiency, accuracy, and employee satisfaction. Here’s why integration matters, and how a consolidated approach can save time, reduce risk, and improve the employee experience. 1. Increased Administrative Burden When each service is managed by a separate vendor, administrative work multiplies. Employees and HR teams may spend extra hours logging into different systems to process payroll, submit benefits updates, or manage compliance tasks. Reconciling employee information across multiple portals and coordinating communications between vendors creates unnecessary complexity, which can distract your team from strategic priorities. 2. Higher Risk of Errors and Compliance Issues Fragmentation can increase the likelihood of costly mistakes. Payroll errors, mismanaged retirement contributions, and insurance coverage gaps often occur when systems do not communicate effectively. A single misalignment can have a ripple effect: Incorrect payroll deductions Late or missing retirement contributions Gaps in insurance coverage or compliance violations With multiple vendors, the risk of these errors and their consequences rises. 3. Limited Visibility and Reporting When each service lives in its own system, it’s hard to get a complete picture of your workforce. Without centralized reporting, many businesses struggle to: Analyze labor costs or benefits spending accurately Identify compliance gaps or coverage issues Track trends in employee engagement and retention Limited visibility makes it difficult to make informed decisions and optimize operations. 4. Compounded Costs Paying multiple vendors for separate services often results in more than just the sum of their fees. Each system typically comes with its own implementation, training, and subscription costs, which can quickly add up. In addition, internal administrative hours spent managing vendor relationships, reconciling conflicting data, or troubleshooting errors create a hidden expense that is often overlooked. Businesses may also face unexpected costs when trying to integrate or transfer data between disconnected platforms, or when compliance issues arise due to misaligned processes. Over time, these scattered costs compound, reducing overall efficiency and limiting resources that could be better spent on strategic growth initiatives. 5. Frustrated Employees The impact of fragmentation extends to employees. They may face confusion about where to access benefits or payroll information, experience delays in issue resolution, or encounter inconsistent communications. This frustration can lead to disengagement, lower productivity, and higher turnover. Businesses that integrate these functions provide a smoother, more cohesive experience for employees, resulting in higher satisfaction, better engagement, and a stronger workplace culture. Why Integration Matters Integrating HR, payroll/HCM, benefits, commercial insurance, and retirement services with a single partner simplifies operations, reduces errors, improves reporting, and enhances the employee experience. Businesses that consolidate services gain: Streamlined administrative processes and reduced duplication of effort Improved accuracy and compliance through connected systems Enhanced visibility into workforce metrics and financials Cost efficiencies by eliminating overlapping fees and redundant systems A more consistent, positive experience for employees By managing these services in a unified platform, your business can focus on growth instead of juggling multiple systems and vendors. Take the Next Step If your business is managing multiple vendors for HR, payroll, benefits, insurance, and retirement, it’s time to consider a more integrated approach. Streamlining these services with a single, high-touch partner like Simco can save time, reduce risk, and create a better experience for both your team and your employees.
August 25, 2025
As the 2025–26 school year gets underway, many employees are navigating the dual pressures of professional responsibilities and family life. For parents of school-aged children, this can mean adjusting to new routines, handling childcare logistics, and managing the emotional ups and downs that often accompany the start of the year. For employers, this season offers an opportunity to demonstrate support and strengthen employee loyalty. Below are nine strategies businesses can adopt to help their workforce balance work and family demands more effectively. Flexible Work Options Flexibility remains one of the most powerful ways to support working parents. Allowing employees to shift their schedules, such as starting earlier or later, or offering hybrid and remote work options helps parents handle school drop-offs, pickups, and unexpected schedule changes. For example, permitting an employee to work from home two mornings a week may relieve the stress of managing transportation while ensuring business needs are still met. When employees feel trusted to manage both work and family responsibilities, engagement and productivity rise. Back-to-School Support The transition into a new school year often involves extra expenses and planning. Employers can ease this burden by organizing back-to-school supply drives, offering stipends for educational expenses, or sharing curated lists of local resources like tutoring programs or after-school care. Some businesses even host “lunch and learn” sessions on topics such as family budgeting or time management during the school year. These gestures show employees that the company understands their life outside of work and wants to help them succeed in both areas. Prioritize Mental Well-Being Back-to-school season can be stressful for the whole family, with shifting routines, homework expectations, and social adjustments. Employers can proactively support mental health by promoting counseling services, stress management programs, or mindfulness workshops. Offering access to telehealth therapy sessions or creating quiet spaces in the office for breaks can make a tangible difference. Focusing on mental well-being helps employees feel cared for and creates a healthier, more resilient workforce overall. Paid Time Off for School Activities Balancing school commitments with work obligations can be difficult without supportive policies. By providing paid time off specifically for school-related events, such as parent-teacher conferences, school plays, or volunteering opportunities, employers can reduce the guilt or anxiety parents may feel about taking time away from work. Even a few hours of school-activity leave per semester can significantly boost morale and demonstrate the company’s commitment to work-life balance. Childcare Assistance Childcare remains one of the greatest stressors for working parents. Businesses can step in by offering childcare subsidies, backup childcare arrangements for emergencies, or partnerships with local providers to secure discounted rates. Employers with larger workforces may explore on-site childcare facilities or after-school program collaborations. Even simply sharing information about community resources and vetted childcare options can make a big difference for employees struggling to find reliable solutions. Open Communication Encouraging honest, ongoing conversations between managers and employees is essential. Managers should be trained to ask about potential school-year challenges, such as altered availability during drop-off hours or the need to leave for school events, without judgment. Creating a culture where employees feel safe discussing these needs allows managers to find practical solutions, like shifting deadlines or redistributing workloads, that benefit both the employee and the organization. Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) EAPs are often underutilized, yet they can be invaluable during the school year. These programs typically offer access to counseling, parenting support, financial planning, and more. Employers should not only remind employees that these resources exist but also explain how they can be used during this time of year. For example, highlighting financial counseling services in September, when school-related expenses spike, makes the EAP more relevant and accessible. Family-Friendly Policies Workplace policies should reflect the realities of family life. Review scheduling practices to avoid early morning or late afternoon meetings when parents are often unavailable. Consider policies that allow parents to swap shifts or trade hours with coworkers. Involving employees in creating or revising family-friendly policies ensures the solutions are practical, widely supported, and foster an inclusive culture that values everyone’s needs. Recognition Matters Acknowledging the extra effort parents put in during the school year can have a lasting impact. Recognition doesn’t have to be large-scale, a personal thank-you note, a shout-out during a team meeting, or a small gift card can go a long way toward showing appreciation. Celebrating milestones, like surviving the first week back to school, helps parents feel seen and valued, reinforcing their commitment to the company. The Bottom Line Supporting employees during the school year goes beyond providing benefits; it’s about creating an empathetic, flexible, and responsive workplace culture. By adopting these strategies, businesses not only help their employees manage family responsibilities with confidence but also foster a more engaged, loyal, and productive workforce.
Is Your Business Ready for New York’s Secure Choice Savings Program (SCSP)?
August 22, 2025
Big changes are on the horizon for New York businesses. Soon, many employers will be required to provide retirement savings options through the state’s Secure Choice Savings Program. If your business doesn’t already offer a retirement plan, now is the time to understand the rules, prepare your payroll, and explore whet

Have a question? Get in touch.